Peter Seitzman, M.D. v. Sun Life Assurance Co. of Canada

 on June 29th, 2012

One of the very few ERISA cases in which the Court awarded counsel fees the plan administrator incurred in defending a claim for disability benefits. Second Circuit affirmed District Court’s award of 50% of administrator’s counsel fees on the basis the claimant presented false testimony and the claim was presented in bad faith.

Download PDF Peter Seitzman, M.D. v. Sun Life Assurance Co. of Canada

Monet Dunham v. Elite Development, Inc.

 on June 18th, 2012

Fact issues preclude summary judgment dismissing claims for prescriptive easement. Issues existed whether the use of the common driveway was hostile or permissive.

Download PDF Monet Dunham v. Elite Development, Inc.

Lillian Hill, deceased Fitzsimmons, petitioner-respondent MERS, appellant

 on June 16th, 2012

Second Department held mortgage lender made out a prima facie case for summary judgment by presentment of certified recorded chain of title inclusive of disputed power of attorney which had not been revoked of record, despite the petitioner’s filing of a notice of pendency prior to the recording of the mortgage. Mortgagee claimed the prior notice of pendency was invalid as it was not supported by a petition seeking possession or an interest in the property, and because the amended petition, which did seek an interest in the property, was not served within 30 days of the notice of pendency as required by the CPLR.

Download PDF Lillian Hill, deceased Fitzsimmons, petitioner-respondent MERS, appellant